| Peyton 83, Adams City 36 | Nov. 29 | Details |
| Lutheran-Parker 75, Peyton 56 | Dec. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 63, Elbert 40 | Dec. 7 | Details |
| Peyton 65, Manitou Springs High School 37 | Dec. 15 | Details |
| Peyton 67, Sargent 24 | Dec. 17 | Details |
| Peyton 93, Calhan 46 | Dec. 19 | Details |
| Peyton 74, Limon 35 | Jan. 12 | Details |
| Peyton 63, Evangelical Christian Academy 41 | Jan. 18 | Details |
| Peyton 75, Miami-Yoder 10 () | Jan. 19 | Details |
| Peyton 93, Calhan 46 | Jan. 23 | Details |
| Peyton 82, non varsity opponent 51 | Jan. 24 | Details |
| Simla 66, Peyton 59 () | Jan. 26 | Details |
| Peyton 71, Colorado Springs School 14 () | Feb. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 85, Pikes Peak Christian 16 () | Feb. 2 | Details |
| Peyton 80, Kiowa 25 () | Feb. 8 | Details |
| Peyton 58, Calhan 40 () | Feb. 9 | Details |
| Peyton 71, Vanguard 48 () | Feb. 16 | Details |
| Peyton 81, CIVA Charter 23 () | Feb. 16 | Details |
| Evangelical Christian Academy 61, Peyton 51 () | Feb. 22 | Details |
| Peyton 76, Calhan 49 | Feb. 27 | Details |
| Vanguard 58, Peyton 38 | Mar. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 65, Springfield 49 | Mar. 8 | Details |
| Peyton 53, Sangre de Cristo 33 | Mar. 14 | Details |
