| St. Mary's 7, Colorado Springs Christian School 6 () | Aug. 31 | Details |
| St. Mary's 21, Mead High School 20 | Sept. 7 | Details |
| Florence 34, St. Mary's 14 () | Sept. 14 | Details |
| Manitou Springs High School 28, St. Mary's 20 () | Sept. 21 | Details |
| St. Mary's 33, Alamosa 28 () | Sept. 28 | Details |
| La Junta 33, St. Mary's 7 () | Oct. 5 | Details |
| Trinidad 48, St. Mary's 41 () | Oct. 12 | Details |
| Lamar 38, St. Mary's 30 () | Oct. 19 | Details |
| St. Mary's 28, Dolores Huerta Preparatory 26 () | Oct. 26 | Details |