| Peyton 2, Cripple Creek-Victor 0 | Sept. 1 | Details |
| South Park 2, Peyton 0 | Sept. 1 | Details |
| Fountain Valley 2, Peyton 1 | Sept. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 2, Crested Butte Community School 1 | Sept. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 2, Vanguard 0 | Sept. 1 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Limon 1 | Sept. 4 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Colorado Springs School 2 () | Sept. 15 | Details |
| Evangelical Christian Academy 3, Peyton 2 () | Sept. 20 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Vanguard 1 () | Sept. 22 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Calhan 2 () | Sept. 27 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Miami-Yoder 0 () | Sept. 29 | Details |
| Simla 3, Peyton 0 | Oct. 4 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Cripple Creek-Victor 0 | Oct. 5 | Details |
| Kiowa 3, Peyton 0 | Oct. 6 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Elbert 2 | Oct. 9 | Details |
| Peyton 3, Pikes Peak Christian 0 | Oct. 11 | Details |
| Peyton 3, CIVA Charter 0 | Oct. 13 | Details |
| Vanguard 3, Peyton 1 () | Oct. 15 | Details |
| Colorado Springs School 3, Peyton 0 () | Oct. 18 | Details |
| Peyton 3, CIVA Charter 0 | Oct. 23 | Details |
| Colorado Springs School 3, Peyton 1 | Oct. 25 | Details |