| Simla 53, Peyton 51 | Dec. 2 | Details |
| Peyton 51, Discovery Canyon 49 | Dec. 12 | Details |
| Manitou Springs High School 52, Peyton 28 | Dec. 17 | Details |
| Peyton 51, Colorado Springs School 33 () | Jan. 7 | Details |
| Lewis-Palmer High 49, Peyton 45 | Jan. 12 | Details |
| Peyton 66, Kiowa 34 () | Jan. 13 | Details |
| Peyton 60, Fountain Valley 33 () | Jan. 17 | Details |
| Peyton 61, Calhan 53 () | Jan. 21 | Details |
| Peyton 54, Rye 48 | Jan. 24 | Details |
| Peyton 100, Miami-Yoder 6 | Jan. 26 | Details |
| Peyton 54, Byers 26 | Jan. 27 | Details |
| Vanguard 49, Peyton 36 () | Feb. 4 | Details |
| Peyton 51, Fountain Valley 41 () | Feb. 7 | Details |
| Peyton 70, Kiowa 42 () | Feb. 9 | Details |
| Peyton 49, Limon 41 | Feb. 11 | Details |
| Evangelical Christian Academy 61, Peyton 44 () | Feb. 13 | Details |
| Peyton vs. Lamar at Peyton | Feb. 16 @ 7 p.m. | Map |
| Peyton 76, Colorado Springs School 12 () | Feb. 17 | Details |
| Peyton 72, Colorado Springs School 42 | Feb. 21 | Details |
| Vanguard 61, Peyton 47 | Feb. 24 | Details |
| Peyton 71, Calhan 64 | Feb. 25 | Details |
| Peyton 57, Resurrection Christian 51 | Mar. 2 | Details |
| Akron 60, Peyton 44 | Mar. 3 | Details |
